Pit Bulls' Deadly Attack On Miniature Pony Has Town Residents In Fear

Two dogs viciously attacked two miniature ponies in a New Trenton barn on Monday.

Rick Kaiser with his miniature ponies after they were attacked by two vicious dogs on Monday, September 24. Photo courtesy Tracey Kaiser.

(New Trenton, Ind.) – Residents in New Trenton are on-edge after two dogs killed a miniature pony.

Those vicious dogs are still at-large after the Monday attack inside a barn belonging to Rick and Tracey Kaiser.

“They killed a pony. They could kill a lot of other stuff,” Rick says.

Rick believes the attack happened sometime Monday at their farm just off U.S. 52. That evening, he walked into his barn to check on the couple’s two ponies, Sweet Pea and Freddy. When he opened the door to the stall, two dogs ran out and ran off.

Sweet Pea was found on the hay-covered floor of the stall dead of an apparent dog attack. Freddy was wounded.

Rick ran to his home to retrieve his gun. By the time he returned with it, the dogs had vanished.

The dogs, Rick says, were obviously pit bulls. One was a white and tan male. The other was a black female.

“We don’t know where they came from. They could still be loose today,” Rick says.

Members of the New Trenton Fire Department and Franklin County Sheriff’s Department spent much of the rest of the day and evening scouring the surrounding area for the attacking dogs. Franklin County Animal Control assistant dog catcher Ray Halpin also responded to the Kaiser’s farm. What he observed substantiated the couple’s claims of a dog attack.

Also, Sweet Pea was not the only animal to fall victim to a dog attack in New Trenton that day. A cat was also found dead in a neighbor’s yard, Halpin said.

New Trenton resident Christeen Mathews says she observed a man in a black dually truck with a wagon attached ditch the dogs in town Monday afternoon. The driver left heading toward Brookville. She saw the dogs running along U.S. 52.

Halpin is urging people with information or who may spot the vicious dogs to come forward with information. Contact the Franklin County Sheriff’s Department at (765) 647-4138 or Franklin County Animal Control at (765) 207-0055.

Halpin wants to find the dogs before another animal, or perhaps a human, becomes a victim.

“With dogs like that, you don’t know what they might do,” he says.

More from Local News


Events

RCCF Announces Chalktoberfest Winners

The 6th annual event took place last Saturday during Osgood's Bricktoberfest.

New Seasons Auction and Estates Named Cincinnati Torch Awards for Ethics Finalist

Torch Award Finalists are selected by the Better Business Bureau (BBB).

AUDIO: Effort Underway to Name Two Bridges in Memory of Local Vietnam Vets

The bridges carry travelers over Tanners Creek in Lawrenceburg.

Lawrenceburg Girls Basketball to Host 5th Annual Hooping for Hope Game

The game vs. Beechwood will support the Joe Burrow Foundation.

Local Sports Report - September 24, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

Career Milestones Highlight ORVC Weekly Report for Sept. 15-20

Nine student athletes earned weekly honors.

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Brantley Gilbert and LINDSEY ELL - What Happens In A Small Town

Reba McEntire Fancy 19:47
Carrie Underwood See You Again 19:43
Waylon Jennings America 19:39
Patty Loveless I'm That Kind Of Girl 19:34