Holton Man Pleas To Baseball Bat Attack

Jeremiah McIntosh

Ripley County Sheriff's Office

(Versailles, Ind.) - A Ripley County man who attacked another man with a baseball bat, killing him, has reached a 20 year plea agreement.

 

Jeremiah McIntosh, 34, of Holton, could have his plea agreement with prosecutors accepted by the Ripley Circuit Court judge during his sentencing in January. McIntosh would serve 17 years in prison and the remaining three on probation, the Osgood Journal reports.

 

In exchange for the plea reached December 20, McIntosh will see a charge of Aggravated Battery dismissed. He had faced up to 70 years in prison.

 

McIntosh was arrested in Florida earlier this year. He had fled there after an April 3 fight at his home with Versailles resident Jeffrey Benham.

 

Witnesses said a mob of about 40 people including Benham had come to McIntosh’s home on Benham Road in Holton just a day after McIntosh was released from jail on a separate charge.

 

McIntosh’s brother claimed Jeremiah was only defending himself when he struck Benham, 48, in the head with the bat. Ripley County deputies arrived on the scene and found Benham on the ground bleeding.

 

Benham died in the hospital two weeks later.

 

LINKS:

 

Man In Baseball Bat Attack Charged With Manslaughter

More from Local News

Events

Oldenburg Academy Names Jason Walke as Director of Academic Innovation

Walke will coordinate immersive educational experiences, including guest speakers, off-campus visits, and service projects.

Ripley County Man Arrested for Burglary in Sunman

The suspect is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Regional Street Sweeping Beginning on Sunday, April 6

Motorists should slow down and be aware of slow-moving equipment and potential lane closures during this mobile operation.

Local Sports Report - April 2, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

South Ripley Varsity Basketball Coach Seve Beach Honored by IBCA

He has a 47-25 record in three seasons with the Raiders.

Switzerland County's Cooper Todd Commits to Anderson University

He will now go on to join the defending HCAC champions.

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Brothers Osborne - Nobody's Nobody

Justin Moore Times Tickin 5:26
Joe Diffie Honky Tonk Attitude 5:23
Brett Eldredge Songs About You 5:19
Kenny Rogers Coward of the County 5:15