Murder Suspect Wants Trial Moved

David Ison.

Fox 59 TV-Indianapolis

(Brookville, Ind.) - David Ison is asking for a change of venue so he can receive a fair trial.

 

The 46-year-old from Fayette County is accused in the five murders on Stipps Hill Road in Laurel on September 25. Roy Napier, his family, and friend Henry Smith were each shot to death, Indiana State Police investigators say by Ison.

 

Last week, Ison’s public defender, Hubert Branstetter, filed a motion asking the trial to be moved based on the media attention the case has received, according to the Richmond Palladium-Item.

 

The newspaper reported the motion stated Ison is unable to receive a fair trial in Franklin County due to prejudicial news reporting that Branstetter said "castigates" the defendant. Various reports have also included "inadmissible evidence and allegations of a past criminal record."

 

Franklin Circuit Court Judge Steven Cox will make the ruling on whether to grant the change of venue.

 

Ison’s next appearance in Franklin County court is Wednesday, November 16. He has previously pleaded not guilty to five counts of murder.

 

Ison remains held at the Ripley County Jail on a charge of Attempted Armed Robbery for a failed holdup at the G.A. Triplett Pharmacy in Osgood last May.

 

LINKS:

 

Ison Pleads Not Guilty To Franklin Co. Murders

 

Ison Charged With Five Murders

 

Laurel Five Laid To Rest

 

Services Set For Metamora Massacre Victims

 

Ison Held On $5M Bond

 

Person of Interest Held In Murder Case

 

Killer Not Among Five Dead

 

ISP: No Persons Of Interest In Five Deaths

 

Questions Abound In Franklin Co. Deaths

 

Five Found Dead In Two Metamora Homes

 

Multiple Homicides Investigated In Franklin Co.

More from Local News

Events

UPDATE: All Westbound Lanes Reopen on Carroll Cropper Bridge

An eastbound single lane closure is continuing.

Survey Shows Majority of Hoosiers Favor Balanced Forest Management of Woodlands

The survey was conducted by Purdue's Department of Forestry and Natural Resources and D. J. Case & Associates.

SDCSC to Host Community Input Sessions Regarding Profile of a Graduate Plan

Profile of a Graduate is part of new strategic plan goals approved by the school board.

Franklin Co. Boys Basketball Enjoys Unique Practice Experience

It is not every day you get to practice at an NBA arena.

Local Sports Report - December 23, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountyonline.com

Record Breakers Highlight ORVC Report for December 15-20

Three ORVC swimmers have set new school records.

On Air

Chelsie playing
Lady A - X - Little Saint Nick

Carrie Underwood X - First Noel 8:31
Brett Eldredge X - Christmas Time Is Here 8:25
Suzy Bogguss X - Two Step Round The Christmas Tree 8:23
Sawyer Brown X - Josheph's Prayer 8:19