911 Calls Detail Holton Tornado's Aftermath

Residents look over the remains of their home after an EF3 tornado struck the town of Holton on March 2

file photo

(Holton, Ind.) - When an EF3 tornado ripped through Holton on March 2, Ripley County Communications became flooded with calls for help.

 

Frantic callers described the horrific aftermath of the devastation done by the twister. The first calls came in at the call center in Versailles just seconds after the stroke of 4:00 that Friday afternoon.

 

“I’m sitting in Holton, Indiana and I just got picked up by the tornado,” David Pennycuff told the dispatcher in a shaken voice.

 

Pennycuff was driving a van on U.S. 50 when he crossed paths with the tornado packing winds of up to 145 MPH. The vehicle was tossed around like a toy.

 

“I’m sitting in my truck after Sizemore’s old garage in somebody’s yard. It’s totally destroyed through here. Oh my God, my back!”

 

HEAR THE AUDIO FROM THE 911 CALLS MADE FOLLOWING THE HOLTON TORNADO ON EAGLE 99.3'S SOUNDBYTES PAGE.

 

Pennycuff was one of dozens transported to area hospitals by EMTs from around Ripley County who responded to the scene.

 

Teresa Arnold placed a 911 call when the home belonging to her sister and her husband – Ted and Brenda Tolbert – was decimated.

 

“In Holton the tornado hit. There are people trapped in trailers,” Arnold said. “There’s two people trapped. It looks like there may be other people trapped in trailers.”

 

The Tolbert’s had each suffered a broken neck. As of last week, they remained at UC Health’s Drake Center rehabilitating from their injuries.

 

Another unidentified caller was clearly upset as he was shouting during his call.

 

“There is a guy that was in his trailer and he went with the trailer! The trailer is gone and he’s laying on the ground. His head is bleeding,” the caller said as he stood in the midst of the destruction along Versailles Street.

 

Dispatchers appeared to remain calm through the calls as they rushed to send EMTs, police, and firefighters to the scene.

 

“I need you to apply pressure to his head with a clean cloth, okay? Just stay on the phone with me,” the dispatcher advised.

 

A group of people could be heard in the background yelling and tending to the injured 58-year-old tornado victim.

 

Two people died in the Holton tornado, which was on the ground for nine miles.

 

Eighteen homes and 14 businesses were destroyed. Ripley County Emergency Management said the total dollar amount of damage was estimated at about $6 million.

 

LINKS:

 

Severe Weather Preparedness Week Is Here

 

Holton Couple Rehabbing From Tornado Injuries

 

Gov. Requests More Storm Assistance

 

IDHS One-Stop Shop In Holton Wednesday

 

Lt. Gov. Skillman To View Holton Tornado Damage

 

Numbers Show How Destructive Tornadoes Were

 

Most Tornado Deaths Involved Trailers

 

Pres. Signs Disaster Declaration For Six Counties

 

Gov. Requests Federal Aid For Six Counties

 

Tetanus Vaccine Clinic Friday In Holton

 

SDMS Sending School Supplies To Tornado Victims

 

Salvation Army In Holton Thurs., Fri.

 

Red Cross Opens Client Assistance Centers

 

Funeral Announced For Second Holton Victim

 

Rep. Frye to Host Disaster Relief Meeting

 

IDHS, FEMA Assess Holton Tornado Damage

 

Holton Tornado Donation Surge Continues

 

Funeral For Tornado Victim Tuesday

 

ISP Give Tornado Donation Tips

 

Tornado Cleanup Underway In Holton

 

NWS Confirms EF3 Tornado In Holton

 

IDHS Gives Latest On Tornado Response Efforts

 

US 50 Closed In Holton Saturday

 

Tornadoes: “It Hit Before We Knew It”

 

More from Local News

Events

Oldenburg Academy Names Jason Walke as Director of Academic Innovation

Walke will coordinate immersive educational experiences, including guest speakers, off-campus visits, and service projects.

Ripley County Man Arrested for Burglary in Sunman

The suspect is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Regional Street Sweeping Beginning on Sunday, April 6

Motorists should slow down and be aware of slow-moving equipment and potential lane closures during this mobile operation.

Local Sports Report - April 2, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

South Ripley Varsity Basketball Coach Seve Beach Honored by IBCA

He has a 47-25 record in three seasons with the Raiders.

Switzerland County's Cooper Todd Commits to Anderson University

He will now go on to join the defending HCAC champions.

On Air

Alison Wiegand playing
Lauren Daigle - You Say - PEC ONLY

Alabama I'll Fly Away - PEC ONLY 8:42
Kris Kristofferson Why Me? 8:36
Tayler Holder and Cory Asbury Climb My Way To Heaven - PEC ONLY 8:32
Jamie O'Neal Somebody's Hero 8:29